Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it. -- Ronald Reagan
Navigate

Blog Home

NTU Home Page

Blog FAQs

About "Government Bytes!"

Support NTU

 
Subscribe
Sign up with NTU's Taxpayer Action Center





 
Blog Contributors
Aleksander Danilov
Guest Blogger

Andrew Moylan
Director of Government Affairs

Dan Barrett
Policy Analyst

David Keating
Senior Counselor

Demian Brady
Senior Policy Analyst

Elizabeth Terrell
Guest Blogger

Jeff Dircksen
Director of Congressional Analysis

Jordan Forbes
Federal Government Affairs Manager

Joshua Culling
State Government Affairs Manager

Kristina Rasmussen
Guest Blogger

Kristine Tuinstra
State Policy Analyst

NTU Gov
Government Affairs & Communications Associate

Paul Gessing
Guest Blogger

Pete Sepp
Vice President for Communications

Rachael Slobodien
Communications Manager

Ross Kaminsky
Blogger

Sam Batkins
Guest Blogger

Tom Horne
Policy Associate

Send to a Friend
Email:
Send to Friend
The Official Blog of National Taxpayers Union

The Opt-Out Cop Out

Posted by Andrew Moylan - October 27, 2009

Yesterday, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) announced a new health care plan that included a revival of sorts for the so-called "public option," or government-run insurance plan. Supposedly as a nod to moderates from states that are not supportive of the government plan, his bill will have a provision allowing states to opt out by 2014. Sounds OK, right? If a state doesn't like the government plan, they can opt out and choose not to participate.

But here's the fine print:
"Those taxes and others required to fund the...public option would be collected from all states, including those that opt out of the plan."
Read that one more time. The massive tax increases associated with this bill, on the order of a half-trillion dollars, will apply to EVERYONE regardless of whether or not their state has opted out. There is no comfort in the opt out provision, no shelter from the tentacles of government reaching inexorably into our health care decisions. Why opt out if you'll have to pay all the taxes but get none of the services (inefficient though they may be)?

Don't let Harry Reid and friends play you. Don't be placated by a phony provision that would do nothing to lessen the blow of this awful bill. Call your Senator today and tell them to oppose this plan. The "opt out" provision is merely to provide political cover for Senators who don't want to take a tough vote. It will only work if you let them.

Call your Senator! 202-224-3121.

Thoughts?   Add Comment -


James Cavanaugh said on Oct 28 2009 at 12:28pm
I knew there would be a catch. Is the opt out an open door to opt out for Cap and Trade? Away to reclaim state soverignty.


bj said on Nov 01 2009 at 11:04am
govt wants YOUR money - it makes your POLs "feel-good" and "important"! ALSO - WEALTHY!
I would contact my "representative" - but feel that it is a waste of my time - to fill-out their 'credit-card' application!