No man's life, liberty, or property are safe while the legislature is in session. -- Mark Twain
Navigate

Blog Home

NTU Home Page

Blog FAQs

About "Government Bytes!"

Support NTU

 
Subscribe
Sign up with NTU's Taxpayer Action Center





 
Blog Contributors
Aleksander Danilov
Guest Blogger

Andrew Moylan
Director of Government Affairs

Dan Barrett
Policy Analyst

David Keating
Senior Counselor

Demian Brady
Senior Policy Analyst

Elizabeth Terrell
Guest Blogger

Jeff Dircksen
Director of Congressional Analysis

Jordan Forbes
Federal Government Affairs Manager

Joshua Culling
State Government Affairs Manager

Kristina Rasmussen
Guest Blogger

Kristine Tuinstra
State Policy Analyst

NTU Gov
Government Affairs & Communications Associate

Paul Gessing
Guest Blogger

Pete Sepp
Vice President for Communications

Rachael Slobodien
Communications Manager

Ross Kaminsky
Blogger

Sam Batkins
Guest Blogger

Tom Horne
Policy Associate

Send to a Friend
Email:
Send to Friend
The Official Blog of National Taxpayers Union

$1 Trillion Health Care Bill Passes...Barely

Posted by Andrew Moylan - November 07, 2009

The House of Representatives just narrowly passed the massive $1 trillion health care bill by a vote of 220-215 (they needed 218 to pass it). Despite the fact that at least 69 Democrats had expressed some sort of opposition to the bill, only 39 had the guts to actually follow through on their statements. Imagine that, somebody saying something and then sticking by it.

These Democrats deployed a very smart argument today in order to justify voting for this monstrosity of a bill. Several claimed that they'd vote for this "flawed" legislation in order to move the process forward and put pressure on the Senate to act. The political undertone to this is: we don't want to hand President Obama a massive loss this early, so we're holding our nose and voting for this in the hopes that we can improve it in conference later. For what it's worth, it is a fool's game to hope that ANYTHING improves in conference.

So, what now? Start saving your pennies, I guess. If the Senate health care bill passes, the President will sign whatever comes out of conference and you'll be stuck with a minimum of $900 billion in new costs over the next ten years. Several analyses have placed the real cost at as much as $1.5 trillion over the first ten years, or more than $2 trillion over a decade when the bill is fully phased in. The House legislation used innumerable gimmicks to artificially reduce its score, including splitting the so-called "doc fix" into another bill to hide a quarter-trillion dollars and not indexing the taxes in the bill for inflation, meaning they'll run deficits in the future if they don't "fix" those provisions like they have to do with the Alternative Minimum Tax.

The real answer to "what now" is that the Senate must act. They have a bill in the works right now, but they haven't seen fit to actually release it to the public so people can review it. In all likelihood, they'll drop it soon before the vote and watch while the American people scramble to read it in its entirety. If/when that happens, President Obama will undoubtedly sign it. It probably won't matter if it follows through on all of his promises, he simply can't NOT sign the thing.

So, get ready America. You're about to get a health care system delivered with the efficiency of the postal service and the compassion of the IRS.

Thoughts?   Add Comment -


PE Zelda said on Nov 08 2009 at 4:24pm
This petition respectfully requests that President Obama keep true to his word and veto HR 3962 should it cross his desk. The president stated that he "would not sign a bill that raises the deficit". HR 3962 does raises the deficit by approximately $1.2. Signing this petition indicates strong opposition to HR 3962. Demand that the president keep his word. Sign here.

http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/vetoHR3962?e

Help us get 5,000,000 signatures!


Grant said on Nov 08 2009 at 9:09pm
You might want to check out the http://www.lastingliberty.com/ piece on the healthcare debate : Bigger Than Healthcare